Back to Suffah

Reflection

# Taddabur: Understanding the Mutashabih Through the Quran Itself: A reflection on Quran 3:7

One interesting thing about Quranic reflection (Taddabur) is that it allows us to contrast different Aya of the Quran and appreciate how one verse makes another more comprehensive. The Quran itself invites us to this exercise:

"Do they not reflect deeply upon the Quran? Had it been from anyone other than Allah, they would certainly have found much contradiction in it." (Quran 4:82).

This verse makes Taddabur particularly fascinating to me. It suggests that reflecting upon the Quran, examining its verses alongside one another and allowing them to illuminate one another is a way of appreciating its divine coherence. If there were contradictions within its message, this process of reflection would expose them.

I encountered an interesting question while reflecting on Quran 3:7.

Some interpretations of this verse suggest that there are verses in the Quran whose interpretation (Ta'wil) is known only to Allah. This immediately raised a question in my mind: If parts of the Quran cannot be explained or elaborated upon to humanity, how do we reconcile that with Allah's statement that He revealed the Quran to the Prophet so that he could explain to people what was revealed to them? (Quran 16:44).

Furthermore, Allah describes the Quran in 2:2 as a Book in which there is no doubt, a guidance for the God-conscious. What could breed greater doubt than perceiving ambiguity in the very guidance meant to illuminate our understanding?

This reflection made me question whether our existing understanding of Quran 3:7 fully captures what Allah intends by the words used in the verse.

I do not approach the Quran with the assumption that it contradicts itself. Rather, I believe its verses should help us understand one another.

Let us uncover this gradually.

1. Muhkamat: The Firm and Decisive Verses
Quran 3:7 says that within the Quran are verses described as Muhkamat.

The Arabic word comes from the root H-K-M, which is also associated with Hukm (judgement, authority or decisive ruling).

This gives us an interesting perspective. Could these be verses whose meanings and instructions are firmly established, providing direct guidance on matters that humanity needs to understand and act upon?

For instance, the Quran contains clear instructions concerning justice, inheritance, marriage, financial dealings and other matters of human conduct.

These are verses whose guidance provides an established foundation for human affairs, including jurisprudence.

2. Mutashabihat: The Verses That Resemble One Another
The other category mentioned is Mutashabihat.

Interestingly, the Arabic word comes from the root Sh-B-H, which is also the root of Tashabuh, meaning resemblance or similarity.

When two things resemble one another, they may appear alike, even when their actual realities or outcomes are different.

This makes me question the common translation of Mutashabihat as simply "ambiguous verses".

Could the word instead be pointing towards verses whose meanings, descriptions or manifestations resemble one another, requiring deeper reflection to distinguish their realities?

If we simply understand Mutashabihat as ambiguous verses, we encounter another question: What is the role of the Prophet, whom Allah sent to explain and elaborate upon the revelation?

There is something particularly interesting about the wording of Quran 3:7.

Allah says:

Wa ma ya'lamu ta'wilahu illallah — "And none knows its Ta'wil except Allah."

The statement is inclusive: none knows its Ta'wil except Allah.

Why does Allah not explicitly include His Messenger here, particularly when other Quranic passages speak of Allah and His Messenger together?

I do not think we should overlook this wording. It should compel us to investigate what Allah means by Ta'wil in this particular context.

3. What Does Ta'wil Actually Mean?
To appreciate this, let us look at the story of Prophet Yusuf (Joseph).

In Quran 12:100, after the fulfilment of his childhood dream, Yusuf says:

"This is the Ta'wil of my vision of old."

Recall his dream in Quran 12:4, where he saw eleven stars, the sun and the moon prostrating before him.

The eventual manifestation of that dream was the coming of his parents and brothers before him, fulfilling what he had seen years earlier.

Here, Ta'wil is not simply an explanation of the dream. It is the eventual manifestation or realisation of what the dream represented.

This distinction is important to my reflection.

Could Ta'wil, in the context of Quran 3:7, refer to the ultimate manifestation and reality of certain Quranic revelations rather than merely their linguistic explanation?

The Quran contains statements about events that are yet to happen. Their ultimate fulfilment, timing and manner of manifestation belong to the knowledge of Allah.

Allah alone possesses complete knowledge of the unseen (Ilm al-Ghayb). Human beings may recognise similarities between unfolding events and Quranic descriptions, but recognising a resemblance does not necessarily mean knowing their actual Ta'wil.

This is where I begin to appreciate the statement in Quran 3:7 differently.

4. The Example of the Prophet's Vision of Makkah
Consider Quran 48:27.

Allah tells the Prophet that he would indeed enter the Sacred Mosque in safety.

The Prophet received this assurance, but the precise timing and circumstances of its fulfilment were not necessarily known to him at the moment of revelation.

The believers trusted the promise. They did not need to possess complete knowledge of how and when it would manifest to have faith in Allah's word.

This brings another dimension to the description of the Rasikhun fil Ilm (those firmly grounded in knowledge) in Quran 3:7.

They say:

"We believe in it; all of it is from our Lord."

Their response is particularly instructive. Their faith does not depend on possessing the complete knowledge of every revelation's ultimate manifestation.

They trust Allah, even where the full reality remains beyond their knowledge.

5. The Example of the Splitting of the Moon
Consider another interesting example in Surah Al-Qamar.

Allah says:

"The Hour has drawn near, and the moon has split." (Quran 54:1).

There have been different interpretations of this verse. Some understand the splitting of the moon as an event that occurred during the Prophet's lifetime, while others have considered its relationship with events associated with the approaching Hour.

Ata ibn Abi Rabah, a student of Ibn Abbas, is among those reported to have understood the verse in relation to a future event.

My interest here is not to settle the historical debate but to highlight something important.

When we begin to identify contemporary or unfolding events with Quranic descriptions simply because they appear similar, we risk claiming knowledge of their ultimate Ta'wil.

Could this be the kind of premature assertion that Quran 3:7 warns us against, particularly when such claims can breed Fitnah, confusion and division?

The resemblance between an event and a Quranic description does not automatically establish that the event is its ultimate manifestation.

Only Allah possesses complete knowledge of the unseen and the ultimate realities of His revelations.

6. What This Reflection Has Taught Me
I am beginning to appreciate the distinction between understanding what Allah has revealed and claiming knowledge of the ultimate reality of everything He has revealed.

We can reflect, explain, investigate and learn from the Quran without pretending to possess knowledge that belongs exclusively to Allah.

Perhaps the warning in Quran 3:7 is not an invitation to abandon reflection on certain verses, but a reminder not to exceed the limits of our knowledge by claiming certainty about their ultimate Ta'wil.

This is a thought-provoking reflection, and I do not claim to be an authority in Tafsir, Arabic grammar or Quranic interpretation.

I am simply sharing how I have been trying to make sense of Allah's guidance through the Quran itself.

I believe that when we allow the Quran to explain itself, we discover a deeper appreciation of its coherence, wisdom and guidance.

These are among the reflections that have compelled my heart to share with the Taddabur community.

Let us continue uncovering the Quran, one Ayah at a time.

Remember to reflect, reflect to remeber

CC:
Nouman Ali Khan
Basit Minhas
Ilham Amin
Hammad Fahim

Yusuf (12:100)
And he raised his parents upon the throne, and they bowed to him in prostration. And he said, "O my father, this is the explanation of my vision of before. My Lord has made it reality. And He was certainly good to me when He took me out of prison and brought you [here] from bedouin life after Satan had induced [estrangement] between me and my brothers. Indeed, my Lord is Subtle in what He wills. Indeed, it is He who is the Knowing, the Wise. (100)
Yusuf (12:4)
[Of these stories mention] when Joseph said to his father, "O my father, indeed I have seen [in a dream] eleven stars and the sun and the moon; I saw them prostrating to me." (4)
An-Nahl (16:44)
[We sent them] with clear proofs and written ordinances. And We revealed to you the message [i.e., the Qur’ān] that you may make clear to the people what was sent down to them and that they might give thought. (44)
Al-Baqarah (2:2)
This is the Book about which there is no doubt, a guidance for those conscious of Allāh - (2)
Ali 'Imran (3:7)
It is He who has sent down to you, [O Muḥammad], the Book; in it are verses [that are] precise - they are the foundation of the Book - and others unspecific. As for those in whose hearts is deviation [from truth], they will follow that of it which is unspecific, seeking discord and seeking an interpretation [suitable to them]. And no one knows its [true] interpretation except Allāh. But those firm in knowledge say, "We believe in it. All [of it] is from our Lord." And no one will be reminded except those of understanding, (7)
An-Nisa (4:82)
Then do they not reflect upon the Qur’ān? If it had been from [any] other than Allāh, they would have found within it much contradiction. (82)
9:08 am · 4 Nov 26 · 0 Views
0 Replies 0 Reposts 0 Quotes 0 Likes 0 Bookmarks
No replies yet
Be the first to add your thoughts

Discover more

There's more to see

Log in or create a free account to read more posts, replies and conversations on Suffah.

Log in Create account
Log in to reply